Note
A friend who reviews my pieces before I post them cautioned me that what is below might be a bit too nerdy for some. I confessed that this was a personal indulgence aimed at the nerdy reader. So, if this isn’t your jam, do feel veery comfortable in skipping it.
Introduction
Evidence of our ancestors supporting community members with disabilities can be found going way back. Around 20,000 years ago, in the Willandra Lakes region of New South Wales, some indigenous people left footprints. Below is an excerpt from https://www.abc.net.au/news/deeptime/willandra-footprints/
“A group of men run quickly, one at 20 kilometres an hour, possibly after an animal.
A woman carrying a baby on her left hip then changes the child to her right hip; another child runs away from the group and returns to them.
A one-legged man hops, using a stick for support.
It’s cold, dry and windy with lots of sand blowing.”
There are other accounts in the anthropological record. They appear randomly but I did a search for ‘evidence for support for people with disabilities in the stone age’ and found some very interesting pages – such as https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2020/06/17/878896381/ancient-bones-offer-clues-to-how-long-ago-humans-cared-for-the-vulnerable
Sumerian philosophy on disability
I was, consequently very interested to encounter a Sumerian poem, Enki and Ninmah, while watching a YouTube video. Sumer was around only about 6,000 years ago, so there’s been a long history of supporting people with disability in the lead up to that civilisation.
Below is an edited portion of the poem from https://etcsl.orinst.ox.ac.uk/section1/tr112.htm
I have edited out other references that are less relevant to my point here. Their removal doesn’t change anything.
Enki and Ninmah drank beer, their hearts became elated, and then Ninmah said to Enki: “Man’s body can be either good or bad and whether I make a fate good or bad depends on my will.
Enki answered Ninmah: “I will counterbalance whatever fate — good or bad — you happen to decide.” Ninmah took clay from the top of the abzu in her hand and she fashioned from it first a man who could not bend his outstretched weak hands. Enki looked at the man who could not bend his outstretched weak hands, and decreed his fate: he appointed him as a servant of the king.
Second, she fashioned one who turned back (?) the light, a man with constantly opened eyes (?). Enki looked at the one who turned back (?) the light, the man with constantly opened eyes (?), and decreed his fate allotting to it the musical arts, making him as the chief …… in the king’s presence.
Third, she fashioned one with both feet broken, one with paralysed feet. Enki looked at the one with both feet broken, the one with paralysed feet and …… him for the work of …… and the silversmith and ……. ( 1 ms. has instead: She fashioned one, a third one, born as an idiot. Enki looked at this one, the one born as an idiot, and decreed his fate: he appointed him as a servant of the king.)
What immediately struck me were Ninmah’s words – “Man’s body can be either good or bad and whether I make a fate good or bad depends on my will” followed by Enki’s – “I will counterbalance whatever fate — good or bad — you happen to decide.”
Here is a sense of fate that might be bad, but it is balanced by a countering compassionate response. True, the protagonists in this poem are gods (and hence mythic fictions), but the fact that it is recorded suggests that it is intended to be instructive to humans. In those days humans didn’t employ abstract impersonal reasoning the way we do. Myths and poems conveyed powerful moral messages. We continue to use storytelling as a primary means of moral influence.
What this poem tells me
I was greatly influenced by the Scottish dancer and choreographer, Claire Cunningham in her BBC Four Thought talk – https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b04n611c
Claire spoke of how disability was just part of the spectrum of being human. This was something I needed to hear back in 2014 as I was becoming accustomed to the understanding that my disability generated by GBS wasn’t the curse it often felt like. It was just a different way of being human – and I needed to adapt gracefully. It was my fate, and getting cranky about it wasn’t helpful to me, or anyone else.
And over 6,000 years ago this was also understood by the Sumerians as a deep philosophical truth – and at the level of the ’ruling class’- the gods.
Why does this matter?
Disability Inclusion has been a ‘bottom up’ matter for the past 1.25 centuries. We have had to advocate for access, inclusion and equity – asking those in power to assent to our requests, and, often, demands. In Sumer, over 6,000 years ago, disability was fate – on the spectrum of being human – and not any kind of moral or spiritual failing. The tyranny of ableism hadn’t yet been assented to by those in power.
This is an important perspective. Ableism is a top-down mindset that sees privilege as more potent than right, inclusion or equity. Notice the difference here. As I write this, the International Day of People with Disability (IDPD) is several weeks away. Rights declared by gods over 6,000 years ago have been re-affirmed by humans via the UN – and the best we can do is a day to ‘celebrate’ disability?
I am no fan of the IDPD. I am not a fan of special ‘days’ in general. I was involved in the IDPD once as a Disability ERG lead – in an effort to make it meaningful. What is better the day after? Mostly nothing because we enable people to discharge their favourable sentiments in a day and go back to inaction.
If disability is genuinely part of the spectrum of being human, which I believe it is, what is the point of having ‘a day’ once a year to highlight it? The poem asserts two sides to disability – fate and response. Having a day to highlight fate isn’t the same thing as having a day to highlight response.
To be fair, a lot of folks do celebrate the many positive responses during the IDPD. But they often do it in a way that suggests the current level and nature of the response is sufficient. The IDPD, to me, feels like it objectifies the person with disability. I would rather see an IDPDA day. That last ‘A’ standing for ‘Action. We could substitute the ‘A’ for another ‘A’ (Access) or ‘E’ (Equity) or ‘I’(Inclusion). In fact, we could have an IPDPAAEI day. But why not have 365 of them each year?
My point here is that Enki’s response to Ninmah’s fate is action, not sentiment. It was respectful caring for an individual’s dignity and worth as a community member – by ensuring they have meaningful and dignified roles.
Concluding thoughts
We don’t know anything about that one-legged guy from 20,000 years ago, other than what we can read from his footprints. We can infer, back then, that the world he lived in wasn’t accessible. There was no ‘Social Model of Disability’ that asserted he was fine, it was just the natural environment that disabled him. There weren’t, we can guess, teams of his tribemates removing rocks from his path.
He was one of them (a member of the ‘us/we’ group), and that was all it took for them to care for him. In the Sumerian mythology the gods created humans by infusing something of themselves into the ‘clay’ from which humans were formed. We humans have something of the gods in us – we are kin. The poetic dialogue between Ninmah and Enki is a dialogue of concern, of care. Ninmah makes disability as part of human fate and Enki responds by accommodating the diversity of human experience and capacity in the world. There is a place for a person with disability in the scheme of things because that scheme reflects diversity, not the uniformity of ableism.
So where are we when it comes to our sense of ‘one of us’? People with disability have ever been supported and sustained in their families, and in their communities when those communities were small and discrete.
It is when ‘us/we’ becomes such a large group that intimate identification and connection are no longer reflexive that problems begin. Evolutionary psychology argues that instinctual ‘in groups’ have a limited size simply because we can’t cognitively manage very large numbers of people.
Christianity sought to address this problem through the ideal of ‘universal love’, but ran into the problem of scale – fracturing into sects and distinctions between those who ‘believe’ and those who don’t. Humanists espouse universalist principles but create ‘rational’ grounds for the exclusion of some people. We are, whether we like it or not, often bounded by our biology and hence limited in our capacity to express our idealism.
Ninmah and Enki are gods in the poem. They don’t have the cognitive limits they imposed on humans, so they can be universalist in their ideals and intent. The poem reminds we humans that ‘we/us’ can be more than we reflexively think or imagine. But the poem isn’t a ‘how to’, it’s just a glimpse of what could be if we ‘elevated’ our perspective on what ‘we/us’ can mean.
The poem also reminds us that Disability Inclusion is very ancient and can/should be an active top-down commitment as well as a bottom-up aspiration. Have we got that balance right?